Quote:Multiple former students said Reynolds was “very touchy” and heard rumors of his “inappropriate behavior with students… especially athletes.” There was also a petition signed by over 50 female students on campus in 2019 saying Reynolds’ behavior had troubled them—in his theology class, he told them to write testimonies about their personal traumas, leading some of the women to believe he was trying to identify the most vulnerable targets. But Reynolds still remained on staff until 2024.